When does a bulk discount pay off? Compare cash tied up in two supplier quotes
A lower unit price can leave less cash in the till. In this worked example, the bulk order first beats the small order on cash after the 14th sale.
Compare both quotes on the same day
A supplier offers 10 units for $90 or 20 for $140. Each sells for $15, and selling one costs another $2 in variable expenses. Each sale brings back $13 before paying the supplier. Assume both orders are paid upfront and sales receipts arrive immediately.
| Purchase and sales | Cash in less cash out | Units on hand |
|---|---|---|
| Buy 10, sell 10 | $13 × 10 − $90 = +$40 | 0 |
| Buy 20, sell 10 | $13 × 10 − $140 = −$10 | 10 |
| Buy 20, sell 13 | +$29 | 7 |
| Buy 20, sell 14 | +$42 | 6 |
Test the supplier's offer against expected demand
To beat the small order’s $40 cash result, solve $13 × units sold − $140 > $40. The first whole number that works is 14.
Unsold inventory still has value. This cash comparison counts the entire supplier payment today. Income statements generally recognise inventory costs as units are sold. If you can reorder the small lot, compare that option using its real freight charge and lead time. Fixed costs and taxes are excluded.
Try your per-order margin in the free workbook preview · See the full workbook